Covers:

1941:

Burl Ives [oudst bekende opname voor Okeh]

1944:

Josh White [als The Riddle Song; begint met de woorden: "I gave my love a cherry"]

1947:

Pied Pipers [idem]

1951:

Susan Reed [idem]

1955:

Eddy Arnold [idem]

1957:

Johnny Mathis [melodie in The Twelfth Of Never, toegeschreven aan Jerry Livingston/Paul Webster]

1957:

Jean Ritchie & Oscar Brand [idem]

1958:

Peggy Lee [idem]

1958:

Pete Seeger [als The Riddle Song]

1960:

Ronnie Hawkins [idem]

1961:

Joni James [idem]

1963:

Tymes [idem]

1963:

Nina Simone [idem]

1963:

Billy J. Kramer [als The Twelfth Of Never]

1963:

Floyd Cramer [idem]

1963:

Richard Farina [idem]

1964:

Bee Gees [idem]

1964:

Cliff Richard [idem]

1964:

Joan Baez [als The Riddle Song]

1965:

Waylon Jennings [idem]

1966:

Charlie Rich

1966:

Slim Whitman [als The Riddle Song]

1966:

Connie Smith

1967:

Sandy Posey

1967:

Lou Rawls

1968:

Andy Williams

1968:

Glen Campbell

1969:

Chi-Lites

1973:

Donny Osmond [n°1 UK]

1974:

Elvis Presley [rehearsal; single in '95]

1975:

Petula Clark [productie: Chips Moman; uitgebracht in '95 op cd Blue Lady - The Nashville Sessions]

1975:

Des O'Connor [alle als The Twelfth Of Never]

1977:

Yvette Horner [in Nashville]

1984:

Nana Mouskouri [als The Riddle Song]

1989:

Olivia Newton-John [als The Twelfth Of Never]

1993:

Jeff Buckley [idem Live at Cin-é]

2005:

Dolly Parton [idem]