Artist: Bradley Kincaid
Author: traditional
Year: 1928
Kentucky radio star on WLS, The Prairie Farmer Station, a powerful National Barn Dance broadcasting from Chicago.
Covers:
Burl Ives [first known recording on Okeh]
Josh White [as The Riddle Song, with opening line: "I gave my love a cherry"]
Pied Pipers [idem]
Susan Reed [idem]
Eddy Arnold [idem]
Johnny Mathis [melody in The Twelfth Of Never, crediting Jerry Livingston/Paul Webster]
Jean Ritchie & Oscar Brand [idem]
Peggy Lee [idem]
Pete Seeger [as The Riddle Song]
Ronnie Hawkins [idem]
Joni James [idem]
Tymes [idem]
Nina Simone [idem]
Billy J. Kramer [as The Twelfth Of Never]
Floyd Cramer [idem]
Richard Farina [idem]
Bee Gees [idem]
Cliff Richard [idem]
Joan Baez [as The Riddle Song]
Waylon Jennings [idem]
Slim Whitman [as The Riddle Song]
Donny Osmond [n°1 UK]
Elvis Presley [rehearsal; single in '95]
Petula Clark [produced by Chips Moman; released in '95 on cd Blue Lady - The Nashville Sessions]
Des O'Connor [all as The Twelfth Of Never]
Yvette Horner [in Nashville]
Nana Mouskouri [as The Riddle Song]
Olivia Newton-John [as The Twelfth Of Never]
Jeff Buckley [idem Live at Cin-é]
Dolly Parton [idem]
Child ballad #46, Captain Wedderburn's Courtship (collected in The British Songster - 1785) shares the same call-and-response form. Apart from that, I Gave My Love A Cherry aka The Riddle Song shares some lyrical elements with 15th century manuscript I Have A Yong Suster, on display in the British Manuscript Museum along with the Magna Carta and McCartney's Yesterday.
If you noticed blunt omissions, mis-interpretations or even out-and-out errors,
please let me know:
Arnold Rypens
Rozenlaan 65
B-2840 Reet (Rumst)